Are humans by nature good?

Look at five-year-old Omran Daqneesh from Aleppo! He’s one of us! He is like our own five year old son or brother. He is like our little David, Kevin, Markus, Eric, Donald, and Phil. He is son of mother earth! What have they done to him and his playmates in Syria? http://time.com/4456905/aleppo-syria-boy-ambulance/

What have we grown ups done to the world and the image of man, not to mention feelings?

“What’s this stuff man is made of “ one of Shakespeare’s characters asked in the 16th century. The same question was asked by philosophers in the ancient Greece, and we still do it in the 21th century. Also here on Psychological Universe, we have given the question much attention in our four posts on Genes and Psychology.http://www.selvuniverset.com/2016/07/06/genetics-and-environment/

images7PHXEGPA

Adaptation and Change

It seems that we human beings are both formidable to adapt to the nature, and also formidable to change it with our minds and hands. This is most likely the nature of man and wo-man. That is probably the true nature of being human. We are both created by our surroundings and at the same time we constantly contribute in recreating nature and environment.

adapting-and-changinga A valley in Thailand were nature and nurture go hand in hand

Yet we have not evaluated the quality of the kind of adaptation and change human beings are capable of. Therefore the most relevant question from the perspective of Psychological Universe’ is: In what direction are we most likely to change the world and nature around us?

And after having answered that question, are we then free to evolve the best in us, and pass it on to our friends, neighbours, colleges and fellow citizens? Or are there certain insurmountable obstacles, certain frames already set by the society that we have to question, and remove, if real change shall happen?

How can we believe in man after this?

Wars in Syria, Yemen, South-Sudan and Middle East, have killed several hundred thousands civilian lives the last years, many of them totally innocent children. If this is man, there is no hope! I mean these are examples of leaderships totally apart from their own population’s lives and needs for as well protection, food, security and a way to provide themselves in their country.

epa04910104 Washed up body of a refugee child who drowned during a failed attempt to sail to the Greek island of Kos, at the shore in the coastal town of Bodrum, Mugla city, Turkey, 02 September 2015. At least 11 Syrian migrants died in boat sank after leaving Turkey for the Greek island of Kos. EPA/DOGAN NEWS AGENCY ATTENTION EDITORSgraphic content ATTENTION EDITORS: PICTURE CONTAINS GRAPHIC CONTENT ; TURKEY OUT
epa04910104 Washed up body of a refugee child who drowned during a failed attempt to sail to the Greek island of Kos, at the shore in the coastal town of Bodrum, Mugla city, Turkey, 02 September 2015. At least 11 Syrian migrants died in boat sank after leaving Turkey for the Greek island of Kos. EPA/DOGAN NEWS AGENCY ATTENTION EDITORSgraphic content
ATTENTION EDITORS: PICTURE CONTAINS GRAPHIC CONTENT ; TURKEY OUT

 

Philospohers thinking humans are of nature bad

This situation lead by human leaders is so critically cruel, so totally inhuman, that it makes many of us believe that cruelty and badness are closer to human nature than goodness and benevolent actions.

Both Augustine and earlier mentioned philosopher Hobbes would agree to that. Also psychoanalyst Freud I might add. On the opposite side of the spectrum we have the french philosopher and writer Rousseau, who argued that man is in his core kind and good.

Most philosophers and thinkers however would say that man is by nature neither good nor bad, or he is both, depending on the circumstances. Here in this article we will follow up recent research on this, as in my article; “Is the biggest treath in the world ,- you and me?” (http://www.selvuniverset.com/2016/03/18/is-the-biggest-treath-in-the-world-you-and-me/ )

So the question at stake is this: Are there any empirical data on children and peoples reactions, that can determine our basic instinct or inclination for one of the two alternatives?

Recent research on natural goodness

Psychologist and doctoral candidate Adrian F. Ward at Harvard University has together with scientists from Yale. been studying people under certain controlled circumstances,  The group of scientists were specialized on evolutionary game theory, moral philosophy, psychology, biology, and mathematics. Their research was pre-designed to tap information on the same essential question: whether our automatic impulse—our first instinct—is to act selfishly or cooperatively.

The studies on grown-ups:

Their group defined decision and behavior in terms of two mechanisms: intuition and reflection. Adrian Ward tells us: “Intuition is often automatic and effortless, leading to actions that occur without insight into the reasons behind them. Reflection, on the other hand, is all about conscious thought—identifying possible behaviors, weighing the costs and benefits of likely outcomes, and rationally deciding on a course of action.”

They then boiled the complexities of basic human nature down to a simple question: Which behavior,- selfishness or cooperation, is intuitive, and which is the product of rational reflection? They were interested in finding out if we cooperate when we overcome our intuitive selfishness with reflective self-control, or do we on the contrary act selfishly when we override our intuitive cooperative impulses with rational self-interest. (Ward et al 2012)poi-2x12From a “prisoner’s dilemma ” game on city tv

The experimental frame was to types of group-based financial decision-making tasks. The scientists used the “prisoner’s dilemma game” and the “public goods game” for this. The games required participants to choose between acting selfishly, – deciding whether to maximize individual benefits at the cost of the group—or cooperatively, deciding to maximize group benefits at the cost of the individual. The results were striking:

In every single study where faster, and more intuitive decisions were needed, it resulted in higher levels of cooperation, whereas slower—that is, more reflective—decisions were associated with higher levels of selfishness. “These results suggest that our first impulse is to cooperate—that Augustine and Hobbes were wrong, and that we are fundamentally “good” creatures after all.” (op.cit)

The studies of human nature continued with 891 persons, to check out if encouraged intuition or forced intuition made any difference on the results. It did not! They ended up with the same result.

To further differentiate, they also did another study with people not accustomed to cooperate with others. In other words these people were seldom directly or indirectly rewarded for unselfish behavior. When these people used intuition in their tasks, there was also little cooperative willingness in their acts.

file_101560_0_Baby_Mirror

Who are you, man?  “Quis est homo?”https://youtu.be/6dg7fnltlT8

What did they find about human nature?

The conclusion seems clear. Human nature tends to be very much oriented towards others and for cooperation with others. But this original natural unselfish human response can be unlearned or discouraged in certain relations and circumstances.

The studies on babies:

On our P.U. Page on Psychology and the “I am “ and “ I am like a novel” posts, we have focused on human babies. (http://www.selvuniverset.com/2016/07/25/how-do-i-become-me/http://www.selvuniverset.com/2016/07/26/how-i-was-born-with-you-me-and-the-others/)

The University of Yale has also done that on an experimental basis, trying to capture the human being before culture takes over. But how can you study infant babies that have no language yet, very little control of impulses, very short attention span, let alone bladder and toilet control. What do you do then?

Tom Stafford says: “It was basically a kind of puppet show; the stage a scene featuring a bright green hill, and the puppets were cut-out shapes with stick on wobbly eyes; a triangle, a square and a circle, each in their own bright colours. What happened next was a short play, as one of the shapes tried to climb the hill, struggling up and falling back down again. Next, the other two shapes got involved, with either one helping the climber up the hill, by pushing up from behind, or the other hindering the climber, by pushing back from above.”

The researchers had a design were after the show the babies were allowed to reach out and grab one of the three figures or puppets. The astonishing result was that the babies reached for the helper, not the climber or the blocking puppet. The babies were believed being able to identify the helper’s good intention, and then identifying with it.

The next test was a play were the babies attention span was measured while watching the following scene: The climber moving towards the uphill helper, and the climber moving towards the uphill hinderer. The result was equally amazing. The babies spent significantly more time in observing the climber’s encounter with the hinderer, than with the helper. How do we interpret this attention?

imagesW8HZ98VQ                                                                Eh…why does the climber approach the hinderer?

The Yale group believed this difference had to do with the babies difficulty in understanding why the climber would approach the hinderer when the climbers intention was to go uphill, and the hinderer’s intention was to draw him downhill. In other words babies with their pre-cultural brains had expectations about how people should act. Not only do they interpret the movement of the shapes as resulting from motivations, but they prefer helping motivations over hindering ones.

Are babies born good?

Tom Stafford concludes: “It shows….a basic instinct to prefer friendly intentions over malicious ones. It is on this foundation that adult morality is built.” (Stafford 2013)babies-4

Psychological Universe concludes: Human beings are of nature most inclined to unselfish acts, with a great propensity to cooperate with others. Besides, infant babies seem to have an innate ability to identify intentions and motives. The babies most naturally prefer and identify with the good guys and the helpers, and don’t really understand the bad guys and the obstructionists’ intentions.

Infant relational psychology have demonstrated the gratifying aspect for the baby, just being in a relation with the caretaker When minimum nutritional needs are met, the human infant’s are more inclined to prefer psychosocially nourishment cooperating with others, than material needs feeding its selfishness.

What do we do now, when we know this?

We need to take the knowledge from these and other studies to our minds. Then we must act upon them in order to change our social, and better our nature environment. Though armed revolution is not the way to go! Then too much blood will probably be shed, and we have had enough of that in the last two centuries.

We need to raise our consciousness about how “rotten baskets make rotten fruit”. We know now that cooperation and unselfish and benevolent acts are more natural for us than egoistical and selfish thinking and conduct.

Western and global societies today however are build upon the notion of continuous economic growth, – for the benefit of all. But we know that this credonis not true any longer. It really means growth for the few,- the upperdogs, at the cost of the many underdogs, and the environment. What we need of expansion is an inside growth of knowledge of what we humans really are capable of, if our societies creates a frame for it.Bushel-of-apples

Then you and I must listen to news on different channels, read papers that are critical to the establishment. We must clarify the trickery of power people defining what is good for us! Then we must vote for leaders that are apt to more than just preserve business and ranking order as usual!

Financial acts must be taxed, and taxing paradises must be stopped. (Ask Bernie Sanders in US, and Labour leaderJeremy Corbin in the UK. You could also go to American economists Pickett and Wilkinson, even Thomas Piketty in France. Why not say hello to sociologist Walther Streeck in Frankfurt at the same time, and return to the US  and listen to economist Robert Reich talking about the disappearing middleclass in America.)

We need the 1000 billions of hidden tax money back to the civil society. And billionaires are also naturally born with the gift of cooperative acting and unselfish deeds. So giving some billions back to the society and welfare through financial and transactional fees and taxes, can be very stimulating for them.

                   

            Humans are by nature good, – and continue to be good when they   are well treated!

image-courtesy-yourkidsed

 

Here is a forbidden song from Israel about human nature in very special surroundings. The song is  found and sung by Moddi: https://youtu.be/nLesWYPkUqQ

 

The Lyrics: “A Matter of Habit”, written by Israeli musician Izhar Ashdot.

[Verse 1 Killing]

Learning to kill is a matter of habit The more you have done it, the better you’re at it It starts on the alleys of Sechem at night The borderlines blur in the evening light A rifle butt bangs on an old rusty door “Where is your father? Get down on the floor!” Soon it gets serious, a curfew’s declared The city falls silent, there’s death in the air Cocking his weapon with shaking fingers Grits his teeth as he’s hugging the trigger Young blood rushes, his heart pounds He knows it gets easier the next time around They’re just objects and shadows, not women and men Learning to kill is a natural thing

[Verse 2 Fear]

Learning to fear is a matter of habit The more you have done it, the better you’re at it News from above reach the street There’s no hope of living, the end is so near Tidings of terror, a raven’s crow Shutter your windows, lock up your homes We’re just a handful, a tiny country Surrounded by evil, they won’t let us be They have hate in their hearts and in all that they bring Learning to fear is a natural thing

[Verse 3 Cruelty]

Cruelty is a matter of habit The more you’ve seen it, the better you’re at it Every boy has a tyrant’s desire Hands behind the head, legs spread wide These are times of danger, times of despair No room for compassion, a soldier can’t care Our neighbors are vermin, they’re used to the blood How can they feel pain when they’re living in the mud? Through cruel routine a soldier is born Ignorance soon turns to evil in war Israel’s land is for Israel’s kin Cruelty comes as a natural thing

 

[Verse 4 Love]

Learning to love is a natural thing It will find a way if you just let it in It will be strange at first, but then you’ll see it That learning to love is a matter of being Being human is a matter of habit A few baby steps, then you get better at it To be for one minute, just now, just recall The opposite side of the towering walls But our hearts have hardened along with our skin We built a bubble and let no one else in We’ll be staring in wonder as the angel falls Then being human will be a matter of course Will be a matter of course

73 thoughts on “Are humans by nature good?”

    1. I like very much people recognizing such work! Thank you!

  1. 引っ越しに踏み切る前に相場を知る事は、とてつもなく需要です。引越しする日にやることはポイントとして2つです。まずは、出ていく部屋では荷物を搬送したのちに管理会社の立会いで部屋のありさまをチェックすることです。

    実際に引っ越しするとなると、手間がかかって面倒だという話をよく聞くのですが、どうやら煩わしい手続きが重なるということが主な要因となっているようです。引っ越しにかかる負担をいかに軽減するかですが、なによりも、ゆとりを持った計画を立てることが大切です。それを出来るだけ大ざっぱに実行することがポイントになります。

    1. Thank you! I hope you enjoyed the article and try to show both in Your job and life that what it says about the real image of man is true!

  2. 8360 709408Spot on with this write-up, I truly assume this web site needs a lot much more consideration. Ill probably be once much more to read far much more, thanks for that info. 899624

    1. You are very welcome back, and I thank you for Your very good response!

  3. Pingback: URL
    1. I will try to read it! It sounds very interesting! Wonder who have written it? They must be very well informed!;-)

    1. Oh, thats the best to hear, because that article is like my precious baby! There lies my hope for the future in a dark world! Thank you so much!

  4. 669748 706339An intriguing discussion is worth comment. I feel which you need to have to write far more on this matter, it could not be a taboo topic but normally individuals are not enough to speak on such topics. Towards the next. Cheers 181903

    1. Thank you Burnworth! I fully agree! The future Depends on it really! This hope! And People like you being perceptive of it! Yeah CU soon I hope!

  5. 931398 276587Couldn?t be developed any much better. Reading this post reminds me of my old room mate! He always kept talking about this. I will forward this report to him. Pretty certain he will possess a great read. Thanks for sharing! 562674

    1. I love you both, both you and Your roomate, for finding interest in such topics like this! Thank you both!

    1. Oh thank you so much for your good comment! I will very much try that from new years on! Thank you so much for your interesting invitation! See you back soon.

  6. 543765 907409cool thanks for reis posting! btw are there feeds to your weblog? Id enjoy to add them to my reader 527789

    1. Hi Funchess! Yes there are, scroll down and search thru your browser and see if you find it! Very nice to hear, thanks!

    1. Thank you so much, I really hope there will be a part two yes, but research and references are still in its beginning, so it will take some time! Me too, eager to have even more hardcore evidence for this fact. I have been observing children and their parents boyh alive and on video takes, and I am totally convinced that we are originally a very nice species, but often ruined by the family climate, and hardships in the country and society we are born into. Hope to see you back soon!

    2. Thank you I hope so! I will search high and low for it!!! Please come back as my very welcome guest!

    1. Thats good to hear, and listen, – you are probably a much better person than you are taught to believe! Thanx a lot!

  7. Helpful information. Fortunate me I discovered your website unintentionally, and I am
    stunned why this coincidence did not took place earlier!
    I bookmarked it.

    1. Thats great to hear! Love to have you as ny visitor and reader1 Thank you!

  8. ある日上役から招集で転勤なんて良くある話です。サラリーマンの立場だと断れないので悲しいですよね。そんな時は異動代くらいは格安にしたいですね。そんな時に試したいのが赤帽や日通のこじんまりした引越しです。自分でやるという選択肢もありますが、やはり悩みます。任せられるものは任せてお気軽に引越ししたほうがいいと考えます。

    1. I am very honoured by your visit! Thank you so much Sayonara Nippon!

  9. I really like your blog.. very nice colors & theme. Did you design this website yourself or did you hire someone to do it for you?

    Plz reply as I’m looking to design my own blog and would like to find out where u got this from.
    thank you

    1. Jacquie! Thank you for liking the design of my siteit! Plz check earlier anwers, I have hundreds of questions on this and there you find it!

  10. Hello, you used to write excellent, but the last several posts have been kinda boring…
    I miss your great writings. Past several posts are just a bit out of track!
    come on!

    1. Ricardo or Cliff! Thank you for commenting so inspiring! I mean I love to hear what my readers think about the choice of topics. I should very much like you to refer to the article or articles you think are off track! Then it’s easy for me to learn and answer or change. Is it page: “Moment and Duration”? or please tell me. Perhaps it is “Crucial for you future”.
      (The vast field of topics pertaining to or Psychological Universe, can sometimes be felt out of track for that special reader. Then I say to all my readers. Hope you find something soon that match your interest! However I hope to see you back soon.)

  11. I think that everything published made a lot of sense.

    But, think on this, suppose you were to create a killer headline?
    I am not saying your content isn’t solid., however what if you added something that makes people desire
    more? I mean Are humans by nature good? – Psychological Universe
    is a little plain. You should peek at Yahoo’s front page and note how they write post titles to grab viewers interested.

    You might add a video or a picture or two to grab readers excited about everything’ve written. Just
    my opinion, it could bring your blog a little livelier.

    1. Great comment! I will check with yahoo as you said: Yes catching others interest is an aim to share this stuff.For a scientificly scholared person like me, used to twenty-thirty grey or white pages packed with dry facts and numbers, without i single picture, let alone video, – I have much to learn on my way to popularizing topics! Thank you so much!

  12. First of all I would like to say superb blog! I had a quick question which I’d like
    to ask if you don’t mind. I was curious to find out how you center yourself and clear your mind before writing.

    I have had a tough time clearing my thoughts in getting my ideas out.
    I truly do enjoy writing however it just seems
    like the first 10 to 15 minutes tend to be wasted simply just trying to figure out how to begin. Any ideas or hints?

    Appreciate it!

    1. Janis hello! Its great to hear that you appreciate my blog like you do! I have never thought of myself as a blogger, but when some collegues wanted to start one, and I was set to launch a pilot Project on running blogs, this was the result. The other blog is only in its pregnancy!
      Clearing my head: I walk for approx 1 hour every day and think and sketches it in my head, and then I try to get time to Write With full job and Family in addition to it! Thanks for commenting!

    1. The best to hear Vernita! very Nice and I thank you so much!

    1. Stefan, I sense you are a quality seeker! Thats what I like With many of my Readers. You cant give them crap, they want gold! check:

    1. Vora, Thank you so much! Nice comment! I’ll try, but to be shure, take a peek in sometime soon!

  13. Its like you read my mind! You appear to know so much about this, like
    you wrote the book in it or something. I think that you could do with a few pics to drive
    the message home a bit, but instead of that, this is fantastic blog.
    A fantastic read. I’ll definitely be back.

    1. Love to hear you nice appraisal of my site! Just check here for pics:

  14. Hmm is anyone else encountering problems with the pictures on this blog loading?

    I’m trying to determine if its a problem on my end or if it’s the
    blog. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.

    1. Hi Frances! I have the same sometimes with some pics. Please try to click on the Picture and you get it blown up, then Return back! It usually corrects the problem! Thank you for telling me!

  15. This is the perfect site for everyone who really wants to
    understand this topic. You realize so much its almost tough to argue
    with you (not that I personally will need to…HaHa).
    You definitely put a new spin on a topic that has been written about for a long time.
    Great stuff, just great!

    1. Wow you know how to be positive and nice with blogwriters like me! I thank you heartily!

  16. Hi, I think your site could be having internet browser compatibility
    issues. Whenever I look at your website in Safari, it looks fine however, if opening
    in IE, it’s got some overlapping issues. I merely wanted to provide you with
    a quick heads up! Aside from that, wonderful website!

    1. Yes I know! Thats it! Click on the photos or page and it will often correct itself! Thank you for stopping by!

  17. Sweet blog! I found it while browsing on Yahoo News.
    Do you have any suggestions on how to get listed in Yahoo News?

    I’ve been trying for a while but I never seem to get there!
    Thank you

    1. Thank you that’s wonderful to hear. I did not know PsychUniv got to Yahoo News! And I haven’t done anything to come there so I dont know!

  18. Hey, you used to write excellent, but the last several posts have been kinda boring…
    I miss your super writings. Past few posts are just a
    little out of track! come on!

    1. Marlene, hey hey, you always tell me this and in the exactly same phrase! I work hard on it! I thank you for telling it, but I often uses other phrases than the one I used last time. Thats makes it not so boring! Try this then:

  19. Helpful info. Lucky me I discovered your website accidentally,
    and I’m shocked why this accident did not happened earlier!
    I bookmarked it.

    1. We are so happy for you, appreciating our website! Thank you for encouraging us to keep up the work! Cheers!

    1. I am thankful for Your positive response on this website! Cool

  20. hi!,I love your writing very so much! percentage we keep up a correspondence extra approximately your post on AOL?
    I require an expert in this house to solve my problem.
    May be that’s you! Taking a look ahead to look you.

    1. Dina, wonderful to hear! We like Your attitude and hope you will be back here soon!

    1. Super feedback from you! It’s so cool to have perceptive Readers like you and we wish to see more of you here! Thank you so much!

  21. 引越しをして、古いテレビの処分を思い立ち、新しい大画面のテレビを設置しました。住民票を転入や転出などの手続きがあるので、最低でも二度は行かざるを得ません。

    新居のリビングはすごく広いので、大型で緻密な画像で、テレビを見たいと考えたからです。

    運輸局に行って手続きするべきであるみたいですが、実際ににはあまりやらないそうです。私もナンバープレートはそのまま東京のものを変えずにいます。これくらいだと予想される値段をあらかじめ知っておけば、吹っ掛けられる心配もありません。ただ、年度末に混む時期には、値段が高騰する場合も多々ありますので、早めに予約する事をお勧めします。

    1. You really know how to encourage a webwriter! I thank you so much and wish you welcome back!

  22. Список продуктов повышающие гемоглобин
    S – Страница 140 из 1164 – Симптомы и лечение
    Узловатая эритема симптомы и лечение
    Коксартроз это что
    Отеки внутренних органов симптомы http://www.conti-plus.com.ua/page/578/

  23. Aw, this was a very nice post. Taking the time and actual effort to produce a really good article…
    but what can I say… I put things off a whole lot
    and don’t manage to get nearly anything done.

    1. If Your read important and valuable stuff, at least that’s not vasting Your time! Thanks a lot for very nice personal comment!

  24. Your style is so unique in comparison to other folks I’ve read stuff
    from. Many thanks for posting when you’ve got the opportunity, Guess I’ll just book mark this site.

    1. That’s a very nice and personal comment! You are a very perceptive and intelligent Reader! Welcome back! And in tthe meantime this is for you to practice:

Comments are closed.